Like a lot of longtime American Horror Story fans, my interest in the series has faded over the last few seasons. I still love the anthology format. I love that every season gets to reinvent itself with a new story, new setting and new collection of deeply damaged people making terrible decisions.
But that’s also the risk of an anthology. Not every story is going to appeal to every viewer, and there have been several recent seasons that just didn’t grab me enough to keep watching.
American Horror Story 13 is different. I am very excited about this season.
Almost every character I would want to see again is coming back, along with many of the actors who made the earlier seasons of AHS so memorable in the first place. That level of talent alone makes me hopeful that Season 13 could be the best American Horror Story season we’ve had in a very long time.
Of course, bringing back beloved characters isn’t enough. If this is going to be the giant AHS reunion longtime fans have been waiting for, I don’t just want nostalgia. I want the things that made me obsessed with this wonderfully deranged show in the first place.
So, before the insanity begins this Thursday, September 24th on Hulu/FX, here are the 13 things I most want to see in American Horror Story 13:
13 Things I Want in American Horror Story 13
1. I Want It to Actually Be Scary
This seems like a low bar for something called American Horror Story, but here we are. Give me dread. Give me disturbing imagery that serves the story. Give me at least one scene that makes me regret watching alone at night. Weird isn’t automatically scary, and shocking isn’t automatically scary either. I want Murder House style scares. Asylum level scares.
2. Jessica Lange Chewing Every Piece of Dialog Possible

You don’t bring Jessica Lange back to have her politely stand in the background while everyone else gets the good material. I want monologues. I want insults. I want emotional devastation. I want Jessica Lange entering a room and immediately making everyone else in it seem less important.
3. Angela Bassett Getting Material Worthy of Angela Bassett
Same rule applies to Angela Bassett. If Angela Bassett is here, use her full range of talents. Give her power. Give her rage. Give her fabulous clothes. Give her something worthy of the presence she brings every single time she appears onscreen.
4. Witches Behaving Badly
I don’t need the Coven characters to suddenly become sensible adults just because the stakes are high. Part of the fun of those characters was that they could be facing an existential supernatural threat and still find time for grudges, vanity, jealousy and spectacularly bad interpersonal decisions. Give me drama amped up to 11 with magic and mayhem thrown in.

5. Evan Peters Being Deeply Unsettling
Few actors have been asked to play as many different varieties of fucked-up as Evan Peters has on this show. After being away from AHS for several seasons, I want his return to remind us exactly why he became such an essential part of the franchise. No one plays deeply unsettling like he does. No spooky season is complete without his signature darkness.
6. Sarah Paulson Having an Emotional Breakdown
Preferably while crying, screaming, running from something horrifying or discovering that her life has somehow become even worse than it was five minutes earlier. It’s tradition. It’s legacy. It’s her signature, and I want 1000x more of it.
7. Actual Consequences
One of the dangers of bringing back characters from all over the AHS universe is that it can turn into a giant parade of LOOK WHO’S BACK! moments. I want the returning characters to matter to the story. Put them in danger. Make their decisions have consequences. Make me genuinely worry about them.
8. Callbacks That Reward Longtime Fans Without Becoming Homework
Absolutely give us Easter eggs and references to earlier seasons. I’ve put in the time. Reward me. But the story still needs to work without requiring viewers to maintain an American Horror Story conspiracy board covered in red string to understand what’s happening. Life is hard enough right now. I don’t need another job.
9. Women Being Complicated, Angry and Occasionally Terrible
This franchise has always been at its best when its women aren’t required to be good people. Give me ambitious women, furious women, selfish women, traumatized women, powerful women and women making absolutely catastrophic decisions.
We’re entering Spooky Female Rage Season. Act accordingly.
10. Ryan Murphy Exercising Restraint for Five Consecutive Minutes
I know. I’m asking a lot.
AHS has always thrived on excess, and I don’t want it suddenly becoming restrained prestige drama. But there’s a difference between delicious excess and throwing every idea anyone had during the writers’ meeting onto the screen.
Sometimes the most disturbing thing you can do is let a moment breathe. Ryan Murphy is really hit or miss. Sometimes, the work is brilliant. Other times, it’s Lizzie Borden. I hope American Horror Story 13 is brilliant and not the huge disappointment Lizzie Borden was.
11. A Story Not Just Spectacle
Give me the gorgeous sets, elaborate costumes, blood, sex, monsters and complete visual insanity. That’s part of the AHS experience. But underneath all of it, I need a story I care about.
If I’m not emotionally invested in what happens to anyone, no amount of beautifully photographed carnage is going to fix it.
12. Something Completely Unhinged That I Never Could Have Predicted
This is the other side of #10. Please exercise restraint. And then, at least once, completely lose your goddamn mind.
I want one of those quintessentially AHS moments when I stare at my television wondering what the hell I’m watching and immediately needing to talk to somebody else who just witnessed it.
13. A Finale That Actually Sticks the Landing
Perhaps the most ambitious request on this entire list. Please, American Horror Story. You have all these characters. You have this absurdly talented cast. You have 13 seasons of mythology to play with.
Know where you’re going.
I don’t need every question answered or every character to get a happy ending. This is AHS; I’d be concerned if everyone ended up emotionally healthy.
I just want the ending to feel like the destination the season was actually building toward and not like a random drop off point.
Because if American Horror Story 13 can deliver even most of these things, I am completely prepared to make this season my entire personality until my next obsession drops.
How To Watch American Horror Story 13

American Horror Story 13 premieres Thursday, September 24 on FX, with episodes also streaming on Hulu in the U.S.
The season kicks off with a three-episode premiere, followed by three more episodes on October 1.
After that, two episodes will drop each Thursday on October 8, 15 and 22, before the 13th and final episode arrives October 29, just in time for Halloween. I’ll have reactions and reviews after the episodes air.
So, clear your Thursday nights, light your candles and prepare to spend the next six weeks wondering what the hell Ryan Murphy is doing to us now. You should also sign up for my newsletter:
Discover more from Felines & Fandom
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
