American Horror Story 13 Ending Explained

The American Horror Story 13 ending brought together witches, demons, familiar faces, and characters from across the anthology’s history for a final showdown between good and evil. But after 13 episodes of building toward the Devil’s victory in his bet with God, the finale, “Devil of a Good Time,” took a few unexpected turns.

Mr. Nas (Paul Anthony Kelly) had been getting closer to the magic number of 100, with Mr. Phibes (John Waters) doing everything in his power to help him reach that milestone. Meanwhile, Cordelia Goode (Sarah Paulson), Mallory (Billie Lourd), and the rest of the coven were running out of options.

The finale eventually gave us a sacrifice, a new generation of witches, a very unexpected family reunion, and one last reminder that evil is never quite as easy to get rid of as we’d like. So what actually happened, and what does it mean for the future of American Horror Story?

Warning: Major spoilers ahead for the American Horror Story 13 finale, “Devil of a Good Time.”

Why Did Mr. Nas Stop His Bet With God?

FX’s “American Horror Story 13” — “Devil Of A Good Time” S13, Episode 13 Pictured: (l-r) Paul Anthony Kelly as Young Mr. Nas, John Waters as Mr. Phibes — CR: FX

For most of the season, Mr. Nas’ age was the countdown hanging over everyone’s heads. The Devil needed to reach 100 to win his bet with God, and Mr. Phibes was determined to help him get there.

In the finale, Phibes gathers 13 men at the Apollyon and gives them cookies laced with crystal meth. The deaths are meant to push Mr. Nas over the finish line, and for a moment, it looks as though the plan is working. His age reaches 99.9.

But then the younger version of Nas intervenes, saving one of the men and stopping the count just short of 100. He then destroys his own physical form, leaving Phibes horrified and confused.

After spending so much of the season watching Phibes work toward this goal, the sudden change is a significant one. The Devil explains that he no longer wants to win the bet and take control of Earth. In fact, he has decided that ruling humanity would take away the part of his existence he actually enjoys: tempting people to do terrible things.

He would rather remain the voice encouraging people to give in to their worst instincts than become the ruler of a world where evil has won outright. Without goodness to corrupt, there would be very little fun in being the Devil.

It’s a strange explanation after 12 episodes of buildup, but it does establish that Mr. Nas was never quite as interested in the final prize as everyone around him believed.

Why Does Satan Let Cordelia Go?

FX’s “American Horror Story 13” — “Devil Of A Good Time” S13, Episode 13 Pictured: (l-r) Sarah Paulson as Cordelia Goode, Paul Anthony Kelly as Young Mr. Nas — CR: Eric Liebowitz/FX

After Cordelia and Queenie (Gabourey Sidibe) are killed in the previous episode, Cordelia finds herself in a particularly awful version of hell. She’s stuck working at a puppy kill shelter, with Nan (Jamie Brewer) alongside her.

It’s a cruelly specific punishment, especially for Cordelia, who refuses to give the Devil the satisfaction of surrendering to him. When Mr. Nas appears, he offers to release her. She still refuses to admit that he has won.

He takes her out of hell anyway, bringing her back to the living world for a conversation in Central Park. He tells her that he has given up on the bet with God and no longer wants to rule Earth. But he still wants something from her: an acknowledgment that he won.

Cordelia refuses to give him that satisfaction. Even after everything that has happened, she isn’t prepared to accept that the Devil has defeated her or the coven.

Mr. Nas also reminds Cordelia that she is part of his lineage. The season previously established that she is his granddaughter, making her connection to the Devil more personal than she ever wanted it to be. He even gives her the Apollyon apartment as an inheritance, while warning her to stay prepared because they may meet again.

It’s not exactly a happy ending for Cordelia. The immediate threat has passed, but the Devil is still out there, and she knows better than to believe that he’s suddenly harmless.

Is Queenie Really Back?

FX’s “American Horror Story 13” — “Devil Of A Good Time” S13, Episode 13 Pictured: (l-r) Sarah Paulson as Cordelia Goode, Gabourey Sidibe as Queenie — CR: Eric Liebowitz/FX

Yes! After Cordelia returns from hell, Queenie appears and explains that Ben (Joey Pollari) rescued her.

Her return gives the coven another reason to keep fighting, even though Cordelia admits that they haven’t actually won. The Devil has abandoned his bet, but that doesn’t mean he’s gone or that evil has disappeared.

The reunion is a welcome moment, particularly after the previous episode left the witches in such a desperate position. But Cordelia knows that simply surviving isn’t enough. They still need to find a way to stop Satan for good.

That’s where Mallory comes in.

What Did Mallory Do in Salem?

Mallory isn’t willing to accept that the coven has reached the end of the road. She uses her powers to travel back in time, returning to the Salem witch trials.

While there, she changes history by preventing the trials from unfolding as they originally did. More importantly, she learns an ancient spell from Sarah Goode that could potentially trap the Devil.

The spell has a connection to the magic used to trap Dorian Gray in his portrait. It offers the witches a way to contain Satan rather than simply fight him, but there’s a catch: it requires an ultimate sacrifice.

When Mallory returns, she and Cordelia realize that they have a possible solution. Unfortunately, the person they need to make that solution work is Ben.

Why Does Ben Have to Sacrifice Himself?

FX’s “American Horror Story 13” — “Madison’s Happy Ending” S13, Episode 11 Pictured: Joey Pollari as Ben — CR: Eric Liebowitz/FX

Ben is not just the Devil’s son. He’s the 13th Antichrist, and that makes him the most powerful of the group.

The season has repeatedly connected the number 13 to Ben’s identity and destiny. Now, the witches learn that his power is also the key to the spell that can trap his father. Because his abilities are tied to Satan, Ben must sacrifice himself for the spell to work.

It’s a particularly cruel turn for Ben. He has finally found happiness with Madison (Emma Roberts), and the two have just welcomed a baby girl. He’s no longer simply the frightened man who spent the season struggling with his connection to the Devil. He has a family and a future he wants to protect.

When Cordelia and Mallory explain what must happen, Ben initially resists. He has every reason to want another option. But he eventually accepts that his sacrifice may be the only way to protect the world and the people he loves.

He also finally makes peace with the number that has haunted him. Rather than being afraid of 13, he recognizes it as part of his destiny.

Ben takes his own life, giving Cordelia and Mallory the power they need to complete the spell. His sacrifice allows the witches to trap Satan inside the painting of The Last Supper, replacing Judas as the 13th guest at the table.

It’s a dramatic image, and it gives the season its long-awaited confrontation between the coven and the Devil. But does it actually mean the witches have won?

Did the Witches Really Defeat the Devil?

Not exactly. The spell traps Satan inside the painting, apparently preventing him from interfering with the world. For a moment, it looks as though Cordelia and Mallory have finally accomplished what the coven set out to do.

But the finale leaves us with a rather important detail: Ben’s ashes drift toward the fireplace.

It’s a small moment, but it raises questions about what has happened to Ben and whether the spell has truly ended the threat. The show has already established that the Devil is something bigger than a physical body. As Mr. Nas himself points out, killing him is like trying to kill a metaphor.

That makes the painting feel less like a permanent solution and more like a temporary containment. Satan may be trapped for now, but evil hasn’t been destroyed.

What Happens to the Coven at the End of American Horror Story 13?

FX’s “American Horror Story 13” — “Devil Of A Good Time” S13, Episode 13 Pictured: (l-r) Sarah Paulson as Cordelia Goode, Emma Roberts as Madison Montgomery — CR: Eric Liebowitz/FX

Despite Ben’s death and the uncertainty surrounding Satan, the finale gives the witches a chance to move forward.

Most of the coven remains in New York, using the Apollyon as their new home base. Rather than retreating into hiding, they begin opening themselves up to the world and helping new witches discover their powers.

Fiona (Jessica Lange) and Constance (also Jessica Lange) remain in New Orleans. Their reunion has already brought Constance closer to the magic she inherited, and she finally manages to produce a fireball of her own. After so much time spent feeling powerless, Constance gets to discover what she’s capable of.

Madison also has a new daughter with Ben, although the baby’s connection to Satan makes her future anything but ordinary. When the Devil appears after the birth, he brings the child back to life and remarks that she has “star power.” Considering who her grandfather is, that’s hardly a reassuring blessing.

The coven has survived, but its future is complicated. Ben is gone, Satan remains a threat, and a new generation of witches is beginning to emerge. Cordelia and the others have plenty of reasons to remain vigilant.

What Does the American Horror Story 13 Finale Mean for Season 14?

FX has already renewed American Horror Story for Season 14, so the finale doesn’t have to serve as the end of the franchise. It does, however, leave several possibilities open.

The witches are still together, the Apollyon has become their new base, and the Devil’s granddaughter is now part of the next generation. Mallory has also demonstrated that time travel and the history of witchcraft could play a role in whatever comes next.

Most importantly, Satan hasn’t been definitively erased from existence. He’s trapped, but the finale makes it clear that the battle between good and evil may never be completely over.

Whether Season 14 returns to the coven, introduces an entirely new story, or brings back familiar faces remains to be seen. For now, the witches have survived another apocalypse, even if the victory came at a devastating cost.


Discover more from Felines & Fandom

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *